The boys are seen playing the game at the Marsh's Residence. Butters comes in, bringing along Father Maxi with him for them to play. They then start playing. Butters tells them about Maxi being a good singer. Maxi then starts preaching about praising the Lord when Randy goes downstairs and sees Maxi with the boys. Randy then proceeds to ridicule Maxi. Due to this, Maxi promptly leaves, with Butters coming after him. Cartman then questions to who had invited Butters to game night.
Western Legends appears again in the Season Twenty-Three episode "Board Girls", where Lola, Red, Annie Knitts, Esther, and Sally Darson are seen playing it at one of the tables in the Board Girls Gaming Club.