Although Cartman, Stan, Kyle and Kenny wrote The Tale of Scrotie McBoogerballs, in an effort to write a truly vulgar book worthy of being banned by parents and schools, the boys were afraid of being punished for their work and instead claimed it had been written by Butters.
Despite the fact the book was written as nothing more that vulgarity for the sake of being vulgar, readers seem to over-analyze the book, claiming that it has deeper meaning than the boys intended. The book's disturbing subject matter however still causes the reader to vomit before even getting past the first sentence of the first paragraph of the first chapter.
Due to the popularity of the first book, Butters proceeded to write a sequel to the story, The Poop That Took a Pee. However, as Butters does not have the sort of extensive and vulgar vocabulary as the boys, the vulgarities in his book are limited to repetitive references to 'poop' and 'pee'. Although this story was not as vulgar as the one written by the boys, readers claimed that the book had deep meanings and that Butters had "gone to his roots", causing the book to be another success.
The book caused a man to murder the Kardashians, a show Butters himself loved, similar to how The Catcher in the Rye supposedly led Mark David Chapman to murder John Lennon in 1980. The murder of the Kardashians caused the public to turn their back on Butters as he was the book's writer and therefore he shares responsibility, thus ruining his status as an author.
Morgan Freeman read the first chapter of it on TV.
The Poop That Took a Pee
By: Leopold Butters Stotch
Douglas had to poop. His butt was all stinky because he had to poop so badly. There was a gross woman named Rebecca who was sunbathing all naked, and she was fat. Douglas walked up to her and said, "I need to poop." "Okay," Rebecca replied, "I like poop." Douglas squatted down over the fat sunbathing lady and went poop. The poop sat there on Rebecca's boobs looking like a wiener.
"Why are we here?" Douglas cried as poop came out his wiener in a long, thin strip. It was wiener poop, which is the grossest poop of all. The pee-pee got on the woman's leg and she screamed, pooping out her boobs. And so when the pee got mixed with the poop it smelled like a butt. And the poop and the pee lived happily ever after. THE END
- This book is shown to be extremely short, with some of its pages being merely a few sentences and an entire chapter being around two pages.
- In South Park: The Stick of Truth, two copies of the book can be found in the drawers of the Stotch Residence's living room.