South Park Bro Down

The South Park Bro Down was a character popularity poll conducted in a knockout format.

The first Bro Down was conducted through South Park's official website between March 16, 2015 to April 9, 2015.

The latest poll was conducted between April 9, 2020 and May 1, 2020 via Facebook, Instagram, Twitter and YouTube.

Format

The popularity poll was contested by 64 characters, with all places randomly drawn. Each round lasts for 3 days (2015) or 24 hours (2020), with a character only requiring a simple majority to advance to the next round.

For all rounds in the 2020 poll, votes from all 4 platforms (Facebook, Instagram, Twitter and YouTube) were combined to make up the final tally.

2015

Complete polling bracket

Round One

Dates: March 16, 2015 to March 19, 2015
Total votes cast: 7,000,979
Average votes per poll: 218,780

Poll Number	Character	Votes	Percentage	Total cast
1	Eric Cartman	779,869	54.42%	1,433,126
	Kevin Stoley	653,257	45.58%
2	Pip Pirrip	70,171	52.14%	134,573
	Mimsy	64,402	47.86%
3	Scott Malkinson	70,056	50.72%	138,129
	Kyle Schwartz	68,073	49.28%
4	Craig Tucker	95,266	53.02%	179,681
	Clyde Donovan	84,415	46.98%
5	Stan Marsh	131,338	54.62%	240,447
	Shelly Marsh	109,109	45.38%
6	Tolkien Black	121,460	51.37%	236,441
	Dougie O'Connell	114,981	48.63%
7	Wendy Testaburger	133,393	53.23%	250,596
	Red	117,203	46.77%
8	Butters Stotch	699,371	58.36%	1,198,453
	Jason White	499,082	41.64%
9	Towelie	97,293	54.89%	177,261
	Lemmiwinks	79,968	45.11%
10	Crab People	89,563	50.88%	176,036
	The Succubus	86,473	49.12%
11	Mr. Kitty	72,988	50.63%	144,155
	Mr. Hankey	71,167	49.34%
12	Woodland Critters	96,780	53.94%	179,415
	Prince of Canada	82,635	46.06%
13	Sexual Harassment Panda	178,021	52.20%	341,067
	ManBearPig	163,046	47.80%
14	Satan	161,332	53.54%	301,329
	Beelzaboot	139,997	46.46%
15	McNuggets	137,536	71.08%	193,504
	Underpants Gnomes	55,968	28.92%
16	Goth Kids	190,253	51.51%	369,336
	Terrance and Phillip	179,083	48.49%
17	Randy Marsh	117,703	64.56%	182,302
	Sharon Marsh	64,599	35.44%
18	Gerald Broflovski	42,012	55.10%	76,250
	Sheila Broflovski	34,238	44.90%
19	Stephen Stotch	57,360	81.31%	70,541
	Laura Tucker	13,181	18.69%
20	Tuong Lu Kim	88,742	63.48%	139,791
	Big Gay Al	51,049	36.52%
21	Chef	57,587	83.27%	69,156
	Jimbo Kern	11,569	16.73%
22	Herbert Garrison	48,053	72.51%	66,270
	Mr. Slave	18,217	27.49%
23	Mr. Mackey	60,670	94.61%	64,124
	Diane Choksondik	3,454	5.39%
24	Officer Barbrady	33,117	50.60%	65,452
	Harrison Yates	32,335	49.40%
25	Kyle Broflovski	87,531	91.76%	95,390
	Kip Drordy	7,859	8.24%
26	Bebe Stevens	84,297	95.20%	88,549
	Annie	4,252	4.80%
27	Timmy Burch	41,775	61.55%	67,875
	Ike Broflovski	26,100	38.45%
28	Jimmy Valmer	53,644	82.22%	65,246
	Nathan	11,602	17.73%
29	Kenny McCormick	62,299	98.17%	63,458
	DogPoo Petuski	1,249	1.83%
30	Tammy Warner	39,307	58.07%	67,693
	Lisa Berger	28,386	41.93%
31	Tweek Tweak	58,662	93.84%	62,515
	Bradley Biggle	3,853	6.16%
32	Scott Tenorman	45,043	71.81%	62,728
	Trent Boyett	17,685	28.19%

Round Two

Dates: March 27, 2015 to March 29, 2015
Total votes cast: 14,272,981
Average votes per poll: 892,061

Poll Number	Character	Votes	Percentage	Total cast
33	Eric Cartman	2,585,507	61.79%	4,184,138
	Pip Pirrip	1,598,631	38.21%
34	Craig Tucker	171,811	53.69%	319,980
	Scott Malkinson	148,169	46.31%
35	Stan Marsh	73,610	79.17%	92,978
	Tolkien Black	19,368	20.83%
36	Butters Stotch	2,612,871	62.66%	4,170,042
	Wendy Testaburger	1,557,171	37.34%
37	Towelie	60,868	73.78%	82,502
	Crab People	21,634	26.22%
38	Woodland Critters	44,424	53.76%	82,633
	Mr. Kitty	38,209	46.24%
39	Satan	50,038	60.88%	82,185
	Sexual Harassment Panda	32,147	39.12%
40	Goth Kids	223,450	51.63%	432,829
	McNuggets	209,379	48.37%
41	Randy Marsh	2,890,791	68.20%	4,238,456
	Gerald Broflovski	1,347,665	31.80%
42	Tuong Lu Kim	48,918	59.91%	81,648
	Stephen Stotch	32,730	40.09%
43	Chef	46,483	56.55%	82,203
	Herbert Garrison	35,720	43.45%
44	Mr. Mackey	55,928	69.16%	80,863
	Officer Barbrady	24,935	30.84%
45	Kyle Broflovski	95,466	91.60%	104,219
	Bebe Stevens	8,753	8.40%
46	Timmy Burch	44,603	52.00%	85,780
	Jimmy Valmer	41,177	48.00%
47	Kenny McCormick	69,458	96.81%	71,750
	Tammy Warner	2,292	3.19%
48	Tweek Tweak	54,176	67.07%	80,775
	Scott Tenorman	26,599	32.93%

Round Three

Dates: March 30, 2015 to April 1, 2015
Total votes cast: 700,294
Average votes per poll: 87,536

Poll Number	Character	Votes	Percentage	Total cast
49	Eric Cartman	60,161	83.65%	71,921
	Craig Tucker	11,760	16.35%
50	Butters Stotch	51,928	52.92%	98,132
	Stan Marsh	46,204	47.08%
51	Towelie	60,930	52.73%	115,553
	Woodland Critters	54,623	47.27%
52	Satan	52,949	50.57%	104,702
	Goth Kids	51,753	49.43%
53	Randy Marsh	62,269	85.25%	73,045
	Tuong Lu Kim	10,776	14.75%
54	Chef	41,961	51.92%	80,813
	Mr. Mackey	38,852	48.08%
55	Kyle Broflovski	66,309	74.82%	88,622
	Timmy Burch	22,313	25.18%
56	Kenny McCormick	60,634	89.82%	67,506
	Tweek Tweak	6,872	10.18%

Final 8

Dates: April 1, 2015 to April 3, 2015
Total votes cast: 685,951
Average votes per poll: 171,487

Poll Number	Character	Votes	Percentage	Total cast
57	Eric Cartman	151,466	51.60%	293,559
	Butters Stotch	142,093	48.40%
58	Towelie	71,319	58.89%	121,107
	Satan	49,788	41.11%
59	Randy Marsh	81,430	84.97%	95,839
	Chef	14,409	15.03%
60	Kenny McCormick	92,261	52.59%	175,446
	Kyle Broflovski	83,185	47.41%

Semi-Finals

Dates: April 3, 2015 to April 5, 2015
Total votes cast: 285,463
Average votes per poll: 142,731

Poll Number	Character	Votes	Percentage	Total cast
61	Eric Cartman	101,227	53.91%	187,776
	Towelie	86,549	46.09%
62	Randy Marsh	71,272	72.96%	97,687
	Kenny McCormick	26,415	27.04%

Final

Dates: April 6, 2015 to April 9, 2015
Total votes cast: 1,689,404

Poll Number	Character	Votes	Percentage	Total cast
63	Randy Marsh	887,121	52.51%	1,689,404
	Eric Cartman	802,283	47.49%

2020

Complete polling bracket

Round One

Dates: April 9, 2020 to April 16, 2020

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
1	Randy Marsh	89%	89%	91.3%	92%
	Underpants Gnomes	11%	11%	8.7%	8%
Total votes cast		115.2K		29,838

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
2	Clyde Frog	63%	62%	62.5%	70%
	Sharon Marsh	37%	38%	37.5%	30%
Total votes cast		86.8K		16,080

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
3	Gerald Broflovski	49%	49%	52.5%	35%
	Terrance and Phillip	51%	51%	47.5%	65%
Total votes cast		94.3K		19,378

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
4	Goth Kids	57%	52%	65.3%	78%
	Sheila Broflovski	43%	48%	34.7%	22%
Total votes cast		118.7K		21,440

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
5	PC Principal	54%	61%	55.4%	70%
	Big Gay Al	46%	39%	44.6%	30%
Total votes cast		182.3K		20,074

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
6	Satan	57%	59%	58.1%	67%
	Mr. Slave	43%	41%	41.9%	33%
Total votes cast		138.2K		18,729

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
7	Tuong Lu Kim	65%	59%	69.9%	76%
	Mr. Hankey	35%	41%	30.1%	24%
Total votes cast		162.8K		21,638

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
8	Herbert Garrison	86%	88%	89.9%	89%
	Catatafish	14%	12%	10.1%	11%
Total votes cast		103.3K		14,959

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
9	Tweek Tweak	89%	81%	84%	86%
	PC Babies	11%	19%	16%	14%
Total votes cast		140.7K		15,499

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
10	Towelie	72%	74%	77.3%	81%
	Harrison Yates	28%	26%	22.7%	19%
Total votes cast		219.8K		25,193

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
11	Crab People	76%	65%	74%	82%
	Bradley Biggle	24%	35%	26%	18%
Total votes cast		117.9K		14,538

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
12	Officer Barbrady	70%	69%	69.3%	77%
	Lemmiwinks	30%	31%	30.7%	23%
Total votes cast		128.7K		11,622

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
13	Stan Marsh	84%	86%	85.7%	91%
	Starvin' Marvin	16%	14%	14.3%	9%
Total votes cast		196.1K		22,266

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
14	Chef	80%	79%	74.4%	79%
	ManBearPig	20%	21%	25.6%	21%
Total votes cast		252.5K		16,694

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
15	Sexual Harassment Panda	34%	23%	41.7%	32%
	Jimbo Kern	66%	77%	58.3%	68%
Total votes cast		133.3K		18,322

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
16	Stephen Stotch	92%	83%	83.6%	84%
	Nichole Daniels	8%	17%	16.4%	16%
Total votes cast		142.4K		10,945

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
17	Eric Cartman	94%	94%	94.8%	96%
	Nathan	6%	6%	5.2%	4%
Total votes cast		304.3K		32,144

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
18	Woodland Critters	64%	58%	53%	38%
	Mimsy	36%	42%	47%	62%
Total votes cast		185.8K		18,625

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
19	Jimmy Valmer	97%	96%	95.2%	96%
	Kevin Stoley	3%	4%	4.8%	4%
Total votes cast		160K		11,182

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
20	Liane Cartman	73%		78.2%	88%
	Darryl Weathers	27%		21.8%	12%
Total votes cast		209.3K		15,944

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
21	Scott Tenorman	31%	32%	63.3%	43%
	Mitch Conner	69%	68%	36.7%	57%
Total votes cast		175K		13,392

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
22	Mr. Mackey	81%	83%	79%	88%
	Memberberries	19%	17%	21%	12%
Total votes cast		200.3K		23,401

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
23	Kyle Broflovski	98%	98%	96.6%	97%
	Dougie O'Connell	2%	2%	3.4%	3%
Total votes cast		149K		14,924

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
24	Tolkien Black	91%	93%	93.8%	93%
	Kip Drordy	9%	7%	6.2%	7%
Total votes cast		168.2K		14,881

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
25	Kenny McCormick	98%	98%	97.2%	98%
	Big Mesquite Murph	2%	2%	2.8%	2%
Total votes cast		189.2K		18,381

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
26	Wendy Testaburger	86%	84%	72.2%	77%
	DogPoo Petuski	14%	16%	27.8%	23%
Total votes cast		142.7K		7,381

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
27	Timmy Burch	89%	88%	90.5%	92%
	Dr. Mephesto	11%	12%	9.5%	8%
Total votes cast		136.7K		12,405

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
28	Ned Gerblanski	26%	18%	21.1%	13%
	Ike Broflovski	74%	82%	78.9%	87%
Total votes cast		216.1K		12,083

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
29	Scott Malkinson	29%	35%	42.4%	32%
	Clyde Donovan	71%	65%	57.6%	68%
Total votes cast		166.7K		9,656

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
30	Butters Stotch	97%	95%	95.2%	96%
	Strong Woman	3%	5%	4.8%	4%
Total votes cast		269.3K		14,185

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
31	Craig Tucker	80%	83%	80.9%	87%
	Aliens	20%	17%	19.1%	13%
Total votes cast		141.1K		18,826

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
32	Bebe Stevens	64%	65%	88.5%	92%
	Najix	36%	35%	11.5%	8%
Total votes cast		137.8K		12,795

Round Two

Dates: April 17, 2020 to April 24, 2020

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
33	Randy Marsh	94%	92%	89.8%	89%
	Clyde Frog	6%	8%	10.2%	11%
Total votes cast		258.7K		17,923

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
34	Goth Kids	31%	35%	47%	62%
	Terrance and Phillip	69%	65%	53%	38%
Total votes cast		257.3K		19,892

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
35	Tuong Lu Kim	76%	61%	65.4%	66%
	PC Principal	24%	39%	34.6%	34%
Total votes cast		334.2K		32,581

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
36	Satan	19%	23%	22.7%	24%
	Herbert Garrison	81%	77%	77.3%	76%
Total votes cast		202.9K		24,115

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
37	Towelie	71%	72%	69.3%	70%
	Officer Barbrady	29%	28%	30.7%	30%
Total votes cast		298K		31,416

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
38	Crab People	16%	10%	19.8%	15%
	Tweek Tweak	84%	90%	80.2%	85%
Total votes cast		207.8K		20,737

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
39	Jimbo Kern	16%	13%	21.1%	16%
	Chef	84%	87%	78.9%	84%
Total votes cast		264.6K		18,012

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
40	Stan Marsh	94%	95%	94.3%	96%
	Stephen Stotch	6%	5%	5.7%	4%
Total votes cast		233.7K		25,354

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
41	Liane Cartman	67%	68%	56.5%	72%
	Woodland Critters	33%	32%	43.5%	28%
Total votes cast		253.5K		16,209

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
42	Eric Cartman	89%	88%	86.6%	85%
	Jimmy Valmer	11%	12%	13.4%	15%
Total votes cast		318.9K		29,508

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
43	Tolkien Black	9%	9%	15.8%	14%
	Kyle Broflovski	91%	91%	84.2%	86%
Total votes cast		285.9K		14,929

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
44	Mr. Mackey	82%	79%	87%	87%
	Mitch Conner	18%	21%	13%	13%
Total votes cast		201.4K		21,253

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
45	Ike Broflovski	42%	49%	41.9%	37%
	Timmy Burch	58%	51%	58.1%	63%
Total votes cast		279.4K		15,775

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
46	Kenny McCormick	95%	94%	92.5%	94%
	Wendy Testaburger	5%	6%	7.5%	6%
Total votes cast		272.6K		20,781

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
47	Craig Tucker	73%	73%	74%	82%
	Clyde Donovan	27%	27%	26%	18%
Total votes cast		225.4K		27,274

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
48	Bebe Stevens	2%	4%	5%	3%
	Butters Stotch	98%	96%	95%	97%
Total votes cast		308.8K		20,594

Round Three

Dates: April 25, 2020 to April 28, 2020

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
49	Tuong Lu Kim	28%	25%	34.3%	32%
	Herbert Garrison	72%	75%	65.7%	68%
Total votes cast		299.5K		21,841

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
50	Randy Marsh	91%	90%	89.3%	89%
	Terrance and Phillip	9%	10%	10.7%	11%
Total votes cast		313.1K		27,147

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
51	Towelie	63%	54%	54.9%	38%
	Tweek Tweak	37%	46%	45.1%	62%
Total votes cast		298.8K		43,990

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
52	Stan Marsh	79%	77%	78.6%	77%
	Chef	21%	23%	21.4%	23%
Total votes cast		317.5K		26,588

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
53	Eric Cartman	95%	92%	90.4%	92%
	Liane Cartman	5%	8%	9.6%	8%
Total votes cast		316.6K		19,268

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
54	Mr. Mackey	22%	17%	28.8%	20%
	Kyle Broflovski	78%	83%	71.2%	80%
Total votes cast		253.9K		17,803

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
55	Craig Tucker	7%	13%	15.4%	13%
	Butters Stotch	93%	87%	84.6%	87%
Total votes cast		303.5K		23,316

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
56	Kenny McCormick	89%	89%	83.1%	89%
	Timmy Burch	11%	11%	16.9%	11%
Total votes cast		240.2K		29,128

Round Four

Date: April 29, 2020

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
57	Kenny McCormick	55%	53%	45.6%	59%
	Butters Stotch	45%	47%	54.4%	41%
Total votes cast		439.1K		30,406

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
58	Eric Cartman	82%	71%	72.2%	74%
	Kyle Broflovski	18%	29%	27.8%	26%
Total votes cast		321.8K		26,531

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
59	Towelie	26%	25%	24.2%	18%
	Stan Marsh	74%	75%	75.8%	82%
Total votes cast		253.2K		26,623

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
60	Randy Marsh	88%	85%	84.5%	88%
	Herbert Garrison	12%	15%	15.5%	12%
Total votes cast		264.9K		18,960

Semi-Finals

Date: April 30, 2020

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
61	Eric Cartman	78%	70%	72.2%	66%
	Kenny McCormick	22%	30%	27.8%	34%
Total votes cast		304.2K		31,223

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
62	Randy Marsh	73%	57%	69.4%	72%
	Stan Marsh	27%	43%	30.6%	28%
Total votes cast		381.1K		27,372

Final

Date: May 1, 2020

Poll Number	Character	FB	IG	TW	YT
63	Randy Marsh	48%	44%	50.1%	38%
	Eric Cartman	52%	56%	49.9%	62%
Total votes cast		657.6K		64,556

Trivia

• The title of the popularity poll is based off "Broadway Bro Down".
• Both the 2015 and 2020 polls had concluded with Randy Marsh and Eric Cartman as finalists.