In the episode, to welcome the new millennium, Jesus Christ gets Rod Stewart to perform a New Year's concert in Las Vegas and invites everyone. Jesus visits Stewart at his mansion in preparation for the concert and is welcomed by his agent. When Stewart is brought in by his nurse, Jesus is shocked to see the state he is in. He is wheelchair-bound, barely able to mumble his words, and suffers from fecal incontinence where he frequently "poops his pants". He is very dependent on his nurse who treats him in a very undignified, condescending manner.
At the millennium concert, Stewart is barely able to sing; he can only mumble "O-oh". He soils himself again and his nurse comes on stage to attend to him. The audience gets very upset and prepares to crucify Jesus once more.
He looks very elderly, with an extreme amount of facial wrinkles, sunken-in cheeks, liver spots, as well as being confined to a wheelchair. He wears a black coat with a marble-like pattern of white streaking through it and a purple shirt.
- "Are You There God? It's Me, Jesus" - Performs at Jesus' millennium concert.
- "200" - He is one of the celebrities suing South Park.
- "201" - He is one of the celebrities suing South Park.