Frosty appeared in student short film Jesus vs. Frosty. A prototype of The Boys accidentally brought a snowman to life with a magic hat, parodying the Rankin/Bass cartoon Frosty the Snowman (1969). Instead of being kind, the snowman is evil and murders Cartman, the only character with a name.
The film features four kids who are very similar of the four main characters of South Park, including a character resembling Cartman, but called "Kenny", and three nameless boys resembling Kyle, Stan, and Kenny.
Frosty had red eyes and a wide mouth with sharp teeth. He wore a top hat and was made out of snow. He also had blue tentacles.