After the boys get involved in a tooth trade racket with Loogie, the American Dental Association has a discussion about the large numbers of missing teeth and tooth fairy money. One of the dentists, Tom Foley, tells the other dentists that he believes that the black market tooth trade is what is happening. However, they write him off as being ridiculous, believing the leader Dr. Roberts' theory that a giant half-chicken half-squirrel is responsible for stealing the teeth. Mr. Foley sets out to prove his theory and goes to Loogie's Ristorante to speak with Loogie, who behaves like a normal child until Foley says he knows about the tooth trade. At the end of the episode, it turns out that the half-chicken half-squirrel was real and starts attacking the dentists.