Warning: this opinion is in a non black woman’s point of view, if you’re a black woman, you can correct me in the comments.
Just like the other 4th grader girls, Nichole Daniels is a character that a lot of fans either love or hate.
Her first appearance on the show was on Cartman finds love and despite being traditionally paired with the only other black kid in the show, she did provide something refreshing on the show.
Black female characters in so many tv shows tend to be either extremely angry and stereotypical or in many cases they’re written in a colorist way, which is an actual trope that mainly affects black actresses and black female characters in media where they are often given Eurocentric features and oftentimes, the black female characters in tv shows and movies are played or voiced by light skinned biracial actresses, even the characters who were previously established as being dark skinned black girls.
I’m not saying light skinned girls can’t be black and biracial girls can’t be dark skinned but unfortunately, Hollywood seems to have a serious issue with colorism and this need to be addressed more.
Also, i don’t dislike mixed actresses because a lot of them are very talented and are just doing their job but they shouldn’t be playing roles dedicated to monoracial black girls.
https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/ButNotTooBlack
Also, let’s take a look at Nichole, she’s not a stereotypical black girl character, she’s obviously dark skinned but she doesn’t have the stereotypes associated with dark skinned black female characters, she isn’t sassy, angry or loud, she’s shown to be a very calm and nice girl, although Nichole is fairly athletic as she is a fan of sports such as volleyball, cheerleading and basketball, she also has a geeky side as seen in Board girls where she take an interest on board games.
But there’s a problem…
Have you noticed that despite Nichole having a lot of potential, she is very underused in the show? I think pairing her with Token might have been the reason, i wonder what could have happened if she was with Kyle instead, they both are basketball lovers who have displayed insecurities towards their ethnic backgrounds a few times(Kyle towards his Jewish faith and Nichole towards her dark skin and kinky hair), it would be AWESOME to them be paired with each other but Trey and Matt wanted to justify Cartman’s gross actions so that’s what we got.
Overall, Nichole is a character with some great potential that could be used more in the future, hopefully she’ll have a major role again.