what is people's least favorite halloween episode?

Mrpetuski·10/30/2021 in Episode Discussion

Allot of people here seem to really like 'pinkeye' but to be honest, it doesn't get a very high score from me as far as south park episodes go.

but there's a couple halloween episodes that i barely enjoy at all; the 'tegridy halloween special', and my least favorite; 'sons a witches'. they both have similar problems; randy being randy, a somewhat generic random monster terrorizing the town trope, and trey dumping his uninteresting marital issues into the episode (which he seems to do allot of). the more times i watch the heidi/cartman arc, the more annoying it becomes, and butters' mummy isn't that much better.

Tegridy Farms Halloween Special Pinkeye Sons A Witches

PetroSpFan·10/30/2021

My least favorite is Tegridy Farms Halloween Special!

Also,i didn't like the ending of Spookyfish 'cause normal Cartman,who is evil tricked Kyle and Stan to send ”Evil” Cartman,the good Cartman back to the evil universe,but i liked the rest of Spookyfish

(Edited by PetroSpFan)

JohnVMaster·10/30/2021

"Korn's Groovy Pirate Ghost Mystery" ssems to be one of the least referenced (by fans) episodes of the show so I'd say that's probably the least popular.

"A Nightnare on Face Time" has some great bits but the overall plot and satire always felt lazy to me and unlike Witches and Tegridy, Randy is an outright malevolent villain here.

Irrewonderful·10/30/2021

Tegridy Halloween was way below any other Halloween episode. I did not enjoy how unlikeable Randy was.

(Edited by Irrewonderful)

Bubby lord·10/30/2021

The scoots and Tegridy Farms Halloween Special

Figgboii·10/31/2021

Why so negative? Who asks for what people hate about a show they love? Why not favorite episodes and talk about what you don't like from them?....Why not say what you liked then say what you didn't like and pick how you thought it would be better.

Sega&Nicktoons fan 3000·10/31/2021

@Figgboii Just because one may like a show doesn't mean they're gonna love every episode. I mean, I see where you're coming from but I personally see nothing wrong with critiquing episodes I may dislike.

(Edited by Sega&Nicktoons fan 3000)

Mrpetuski·10/31/2021

@Figgboii mainly because there was already 2 posts this month inquiring about people's favorite halloween episode. to save you the trouble of scrolling down, i said i liked korn, hell on earth, and scoots.

"Why not say what you liked then say what you didn't like and pick how you thought it would be better." - that's generally exactly what i try and do. i just didn't bother so much this time because again, the praises for halloween episodes have been said already, and because with sons a witches in particular and the tegridy special mostly as well, i really struggle to find anything good to say. fixing these episodes would be a matter of rewriting them from start to finish.

So why talk about them at all? well let me put it this way, your comment about my comment is just as critical as my comment is about the show. whatever the value is in being negative, you presumably already subconconsciously or consciously understand it. south park prides itself on being highly critical of everything and everyone including itself, that's part of the reason why i like ~95% of the episodes.

Snake Frackle·10/31/2021

I didn't really like "Nightmare on Face Time".

What do you think?