Shelly and Stan should do it together

That sounds like it would go too much against stan's character. remember that stan is kind of a hippie, and also, despite frequently being annoyed and embarrassed by him, he doesn't hate randy. he expresses his annoyence in healthy ways like music, or just telling him off directly. it's not being bottled up to where he might snap randomly.

This sounds more like the m.o of butters snapping against his dad in a psychotic episode.

@Mrpetuski I understand what you mean, but what I mean is, Randy made his own son cheat and made him kill the alien in Pineward Derby, maybe just once fans would love to see Stan’s darker side and unhinged moments of Stan calling his own father a worthless piece of trash

Remember in the City Part Of Town Randy kicked Kenny that is another reason to hate Randy.

@Sam Katawazi i think the most violent stan has gotten previously (from his own initiative) is in whale whores, and his motive wasn't to do with vengeance or after the fact justice, rather he sees himself coming to the defence of someone or something in that moment. this is how in line with how i pictre stan's morality; he's interested in preventing future or present harm but he's not the sort of character that goes out of his way to punish people for harm already done.

So maybe this scene could work if randy starts blowing people up again, and beating him half to death is the only way to stop him. otherwise i think someone else has to give randy his medicine.

That's more of a shelly thing

Shelly should kick Randy. And Jimbo too because of what Randy made him do in the hospital ...

Maybe Stan should watch Randy get beaten up and not caring about a thing

@sam Katawazi I support Stan.

That would be out of character for him as he's not a violent kid or implusive. He could pay Cartman to do it though